what was ancient greek democracy like? : r/AskHistorians - Reddit
2012年1月2日 · Really, though, the concept of "Greek" democracy is really nonexistent. Every Greek city-state did pretty much everything different from each other city. Even the Spartans had some elements of democracy in their government. The Gerousia was a representative body much like the early American senate.
Are we giving Ancient Greece too much credit for modern …
France and Iberia, which were parts of the Roman Empire, and partially influenced by Ancient Greek colonies, remained feudal, non-democratic monarchies between the Roman era up until the 1700s. The peoples of what are now Western, Central and Northern European nations had barely any contact with Ancient Athens.
How did Greek democracy work? : r/AskHistorians - Reddit
2013年6月27日 · The Athenian democracy has two main phases, from the overthrow of the Pisistratids in 510 to the end of the Peloponnesian War in 404. First there is the Cleisthenid democracy, followed by the radical democracy under Pericles.
What are the pros and cons of Athenian style Democracy?
2015年2月6日 · The Democracy survived the existential crisis of the Peloponnesian War and conquest by Philip, but there was nothing systemic to protect the individual. This would have most likely made it untenable on a larger scale, and caused it to collapse under its own weight like it did for Rome after the Social War, but in the confines of Attica and the ...
Were the ancient greeks the only ones that came up with the
‘Democracy’ Greek government as democratic is extremely romanticized. At its most functional it was an oligarchy. At its worst it was a tyranny that relied on mob violence against one’s enemies. They really didn’t come up with the idea nor was really modern democracy a …
How did the idea and practice of democracy develop in Athens
2014年7月1日 · The other major candidate for the invention of Greek democracy is a reform bill associated with Ephialtes and supported by Pericles in 462/1 BCE, which set the stage for what we generally think of Athenian democracy. And even then, it does not compare very well to what we call democracy today.
How different was the Ancient Greek democracy from the ... - Reddit
2013年11月28日 · Firstly the term democracy itself is a very debatable subject so pinpointing a specific definition of one that has universal acceptance is impossible, plus there exists many varieties of democracy, and more importantly the idea of democracy is a very fluid idea and doesn't necessarily encompass solely the political and legal apparatus, a number ...
Ancient Greece is remembered today as the birthplace of …
2015年10月2日 · Well, Greek democracy isn't really where modern democracy came from--there was a significant interruption, and modern democracy is from a separate tradition and quite different ideologically (human rights vs citizen egalitarianism). The connection to Greece is in many respects rhetorical--"Greece" has been, in literature and philosophy, the ...
What is the common reason that ancient Rome and Greece's …
2013年7月21日 · I will answer this question in regards to ancient Greece and her democracy. First and foremost, it must be understood that "democracy" was completely different in the 5th century B.C., when it really flourished in Athens and other city-states, as opposed to what we know as democracy today. Since Athens was the first, I will use them as my example.
What exactly was Athenian democracy? Was it truly as radically
2017年11月25日 · To understand what democracy was and how it worked, we need to see it in the context of the common political systems of the Greek world. Generally speaking, Greek political communities consisted of a carefully defined population of citizens (usually those born to free parents native to the territory), plus freeborn non-citizens (usually ...