Was Peggie Castle married? She was married to Arthur Sylvan Morgenstern Sr. from October 17, 1970 to April 30, 1973, William McGarry from July 24, 1955 to January 1970, Robert Hilton Rains from January 4, 1951 to April 29, 1954, and Revis T. Call from August 19, 1945 to 1951.